Other Candid sites

Candid Financial Advice
Financial advice for a fraction of the usual cost.

Compare Fund Platforms
The UK's only fund platform comparison site for private investors.

Calculator over 80 Calculators!

Covering almost all your money needs - use them.

Shares ISA Tax Savings

Calculator Could holding your stocks and shares investments in an Individual Savings Account (ISA) save you any tax? Use this calculator to find out.

Random Jargon

Compulsory Purchase Annuity Annuities

The annuity you must purchase with your pension fund by age 75.

| Printable version | A A A |

Author Photo

Is your ISA stuck with fund supermarkets?

Investment | ISAs

By Justin Modray, published 02 February 2011.
Helpful? 41

If your ISA is held with a fund supermarket you might get an unpleasant surprise should you decide to transfer it elsewhere.

Fund supermarkets (or 'platforms' as they're sometimes called) are a genuinely useful innovation. They allow you to keep your investments in one place, even though he underlying funds may be run by a variety of different management groups.

The end result is far less paperwork, simpler and faster fund switching, a single valuation showing your whole portfolio and potentially better deals via some discount brokers. You can read more in our Using Fund Supermarkets Action Plan.

But there's a potential flaw that affects ISA investors with Cofunds, FundsNetwork and Skandia, three of the largest supermarkets. They won't let you move your ISA investments 'as is' to another supermarket or platform. And, worse still, FundsNetwork also refuses to offer this option for non-ISA investors when their investments total less than £40,000 - even though the other major supermarkets and platforms are all happy to do so with no minimum.

The process of transferring investments 'as is', without having to sell then repurchase, is usually referred to as 're-registration' or an 'in specie' transfer. And while all fund supermarkets and platforms are more than happy to accept ISA re-registrations from elsewhere, Cofunds, FundsNetwork and Skandia are not so obliging should you want to leave. Being cynical, there's little incentive for them to do as it increases the risk of losing business to competitors.

These supermarkets will only let you transfer your ISA elsewhere as cash, so you'll have to sell the investments then repurchase on the new platform. Not only is this inconvenient and potentially expensive if you get clobbered with a new set of initial charges, but you run the risk of your money being out of the market for a few days.

And some of those that do allow ISA re-registration away from their platform will charge you for doing so.

The FSA has said that all fund supermarkets and platforms must offer re-registration to other platforms by the end of 2012, but that's little consolation if you're stuck with a supermarket you don't like meanwhile. Annoyingly, if you find yourself in this situation then the only thing you can (aside from moaning loudly at the offending provider) is to sell the investments and re-invest the cash elsewhere (using an ISA transfer form from the new provider).

Here is where the main fund supermarkets and platforms currently stand on re-registration to other platforms:

Supermarket/PlatformISA Re-registration out?Charge
Alliance Trust Savings i.nvest yes £15 per fund/stock
Ascentric yes Free
AXA Elevate yes Free
Cofunds no N/A
Fidelity FundsNetwork no N/A
Fundsdirect yes Free
Hargreaves Lansdown Vantage yes £24 per fund/stock
Nucleus Financial yes Free
Skandia no N/A
Transact yes Free

A final thought. Even where re-registration is allowed it can be a very slow process, sometimes taking up to two months - tedious. The platforms are apparently working with fund groups to develop an automated system that should speed this up, but I'd expect a long wait before this sees the light of day.

If you found this article helpful, please add your vote by clicking here.

Readers' Comments (0) - To post a comment please register or login .